The distinction is **venue + contract**, not genre:
| Production | Broadway? | Play? | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Lehman Trilogy | Yes | Yes | Play on Broadway |
| Hamilton | Yes | No | Musical on Broadway |
| Slave Play (2020) | Yes | Yes | Play on Broadway |
| Hamlet (Off-Broadway, 2017) | No | Yes | Play, not Broadway |
| The Fantasticks (Off-Broadway, 42 yrs) | No | No | Musical, not Broadway |
| Aspect | Broadway Show | Play (General) |
|---|---|---|
| Venue requirement | Specific 41 theatres | Any theatre worldwide |
| Union contracts | Production Contract (highest) | Varies (LOA, LORT, showcase, etc.) |
| Typical budget | $10M–25M (musicals), $3M–8M (plays) | $0–$5M (highly variable) |
| Marketing/Press | Industry-wide attention | Local/niche usually |
| Run expectation | Open-ended (recoupment goal) | Often limited (4–16 weeks) |
People equate "Broadway" with "musical" because **~70% of Broadway shows are musicals** (higher ticket prices, longer runs). But plays are regularly on Broadway—just fewer.
A play can be a Broadway show. A Broadway show can be a play. They're orthogonal categories.