There is no textual evidence in J.D. Salinger's The Catcher in the Rye suggesting Holden Caulfield possesses any capacity for murder. While the character is deeply troubled, alienated, and fiercely critical of what he perceives as "phoniness" in adult society, he is never portrayed as violent or dangerous to others.
The idea that Caulfield would have killed John Lennon originated as an internet meme, likely fueled by the real-life tragedy of Mark David Chapman (who was obsessed with the novel) assassinating Lennon in 1980. However, Chapman's actions reflect his own pathology, not the character's nature. Salinger's protagonist channels his pain into cynicism, withdrawal, and protective instincts toward innocence—symbolized by his "catcher in the rye" fantasy—not aggression.
Literary analysis consistently characterizes Holden as a wounded idealist, not a potential killer.