| Season | Runner-Up |
|---|---|
| 1 | Justin Guarini |
| 2 | Clay Aiken |
| 3 | Diana DeGarmo |
| 4 | Bo Bice |
| 5 | Katharine McPhee |
| 6 | Blake Lewis |
| 7 | David Archuleta |
| 8 | Adam Lambert |
Correction: Season 7 runner-up was David Archuleta (David Cook won). Season 8 runner-up was Adam Lambert (Kris Allen won).