Despite Frank Sinatra's well-documented patronage of Toots Shor's (the legendary Manhattan saloon, 1940s–1971) and his habit of signing autographs for fans and staff, no authenticated Toots Shor's menu signed by Sinatra has surfaced in major auction records (Heritage, RR Auction, Sotheby's) or dedicated Sinatra memorabilia registries.
Seek authentication from PSA/DNA, JSA, or Beckett Authentication—specialists in Sinatra. Provenance is critical: a period photo of Sinatra signing it, a letter from a waiter/owner, or documented chain of custody. Without it, assume it's a reproduction.
The Sinatra-Toots Shor's connection is real. The signed menu? Almost certainly not.