Fact Check: Simon Cowell, Natasha Bedingfield, and "Arms Wide Open"
No — and the premise is incorrect on two counts:
- "Arms Wide Open" is by Creed — written by Scott Stapp (lead singer), released in 2000 on Human Clay. It hit #1 on Mainstream Rock and #24 on the Hot 100.
- Natasha Bedingfield wrote and sang "Unwritten," "Pocketful of Sunshine," "These Words" — not "Arms Wide Open."
Possible Confusion Sources
- Both songs are inspirational, mid-tempo, late-90s/early-00s anthems.
- Bedingfield's "Unwritten" (2004) and Creed's "Arms Wide Open" (2000) both appear in graduations, montages, and feel-good contexts.
- Simon Cowell may have confused them in a live moment — but no verified quote exists.
Fact: Scott Stapp wrote "Arms Wide Open" for his newborn son. Natasha Bedingfield had no involvement.