Did Jesse Lacey Write for Taking Back Sunday? No—Here's the Connection
No. Jesse Lacey is the frontman and primary songwriter of Brand New. He was never a member of Taking Back Sunday.
Why the Confusion Exists
- Same scene, same time: Both bands emerged from the Long Island/Jersey emo/post-hardcore scene circa 2000–2003.
- Personnel crossover: John Nolan (Taking Back Sunday's original guitarist/co-vocalist) left TBS in 2003, briefly joined Brand New (appears on Deja Entendu), then formed Straylight Run. This created a tangled family tree.
- Lyrical overlap: Both bands wrote raw, confessional, narratively dense songs about betrayal, faith, and youth—fans conflate the voices.
Actual Songwriting Credits
- Taking Back Sunday (early): Adam Lazzara (lyrics/vocals) + John Nolan (guitar/lyrics/vocals).
- Taking Back Sunday (post-2003): Lazzara + Eddie Reyes (guitar) + others.
- Brand New: Jesse Lacey (lyrics/vocals/guitar) + Vincent Accardi (guitar) + Garrett Tierney (bass) + Brian Lane (drums).
Lacey and Lazzara had a public feud (referenced in Brand New's "Seventy Times 7" and TBS's "There's No 'I' in Team"), which only fueled the mythology. Two distinct bands. Two distinct voices. Both essential to that era.