Selling Hymn Recordings: Copyright, Licensing, and Legal Compliance Guide
Recording and selling hymns with friends involves layered intellectual property considerations. Here’s a structured compliance framework.
1. Copyright Status Determination
- Public Domain (PD): Hymns published before 1929 (US) are PD—melody, lyrics, harmony free to use. Examples: "Amazing Grace," "Holy, Holy, Holy," "A Mighty Fortress."
• Verify: Check Hymnary.org, CyberHymnal, or IMSLP for publication dates.
- Under Copyright: Post-1928 works require licensing. Most modern hymnals (e.g., Glory to God, Worship) contain copyrighted arrangements/texts.
2. Required Licenses for Copyrighted Material
- Mechanical License: For audio-only reproduction/distribution (CDs, downloads, streams). Obtain via Harry Fox Agency (Songfile), Easy Song Licensing, or direct from publisher (Hope Publishing, GIA, OCP, CCLI). Rate: 12.4¢/copy (5 min) or 2.39¢/minute.
- Synchronization License: If pairing audio with video (YouTube, DVD). Negotiated directly with publisher—no statutory rate.
- Print License: For lyric sheets, chord charts, sheet music PDFs sold/bundled.
3. Common Misconceptions
- "We changed the arrangement" → still derivative work, needs license.
- "Non-profit/church use" → not automatically fair use; 17 USC §110 exemptions are narrow (worship services only, not distribution).
- "Fair use" → rarely applies to commercial distribution of entire works.
- "Hymns are traditional" → many "traditional" texts have copyrighted arrangements/translations.
4. Practical Compliance Steps
- Catalog each hymn: title, author, composer, arranger, publication year, publisher.
- Separate PD vs. copyrighted tracks.
- For copyrighted tracks: contact publisher(s) for mechanical licenses before pressing/distributing.
- Budget: ~$15–25/song for 100–500 units via Songfile.
- Keep license documentation; display copyright notices on packaging.
5. Alternative: CCLI / OneLicense
If your group is a church, CCLI Church Copyright License covers congregational recording distribution within the congregation only (not public sale). For public sales, mechanical licenses remain required.
Bottom line: PD hymns = green light. Copyrighted hymns = license first, sell second. Consult an IP attorney for commercial-scale projects.