A.E. Stallings’ poem Another Lullaby for Insomniacs does something formally daring and emotionally devastating: it sustains the second person (“you”) from first word to last.
Most poems use “I” (confession) or “he/she/they” (observation). “You” collapses the distance. The reader is the insomniac—racing thoughts, clock-watching, bargaining with the dark. There’s no safe perch to observe from. You’re in the bed, counting the hours, negotiating with the ceiling.
Sustaining second person for an entire poem is technically difficult—repetition risks monotony. Stallings avoids this by varying the address: sometimes imperative (“Lie still”), sometimes descriptive (“Your thoughts are flies”), sometimes conspiratorial (“We both know”). The “you” breathes.
The result: a lullaby that doesn’t soothe—it accompanies. And that’s what the insomniac actually needs.