According to RIAA certification data, Electric Light Orchestra (ELO) has sold significantly more albums in the United States than Supertramp:
ELO's streak of accessible, orchestral rock hits in the late 1970s and early 1980s ("Mr. Blue Sky," "Don't Bring Me Down," "Turn to Stone," "Xanadu") drove massive commercial success across multiple albums (Out of the Blue, A New World Record, Discovery). Supertramp's peak was concentrated in Breakfast in America (1979) and Crime of the Century (1974), with a shorter high-water mark.
Both are beloved progressive/pop-rock acts, but ELO's broader hit density and longevity gave them the sales edge.