No single consensus exists—innovation takes many forms. But these five composers revolutionized musical language in distinct, enduring ways:
Innovation: Systematic mastery of counterpoint and functional harmony. Well-Tempered Clavier (all 24 keys), Art of Fugue, Brandenburg Concertos. His chorale harmonizations became the grammar of Western tonal music.
Innovation: Melodic invention and formal perfection across every genre—opera (Figaro, Don Giovanni, Magic Flute), symphony (41), concerto (27 piano), chamber, sacred. Synthesized galant, learned, and dramatic styles into a universal language.
Innovation: Emotional intensity as structural principle. Expanded sonata form, scherzo replacing minuet, choral finale (Sym. 9), motivic saturation (Sym. 5), late quartets' fragmentation. Made the composer a heroic individual.
Innovation: Music drama / Gesamtkunstwerk. Leitmotifs (musical tags for characters/ideas) woven into endless melody. Tristan und Isolde harmony (Tristan chord) → atonality. Ring Cycle = 15-hour unified myth.
Innovation: Impressionism / coloristic harmony. Whole-tone, pentatonic, modal scales; parallel chords; timbre as structure. Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune, La Mer, Pelléas et Mélisande. Freed harmony from functional progression.
Each transformed what music could be. The "most innovative" depends on which parameter—harmony, form, timbre, time, concept—you prioritize.