Handel vs. Gershwin: Popularity in Different Spheres
Different eras, different metrics, different definitions of "popular."
George Frideric Handel (1685–1759)
- Baroque superstar in London — opera and oratorio impresario.
- Messiah (1741) — most performed choral work in history; annual tradition globally.
- Dominated 18th-century British musical life; royal patronage, public concerts, publishing revenue.
George Gershwin (1898–1937)
- Jazz Age icon — fused classical forms with jazz/blues/popular idioms.
- Rhapsody in Blue (1924), An American in Paris (1928), Porgy and Bess (1935) — crossover landmarks.
- Shaped Broadway, film scoring, American concert music. Ubiquitous in pops concerts, jazz repertoire, cultural literacy.
Comparison
- Classical/choral repertoire: Handel dominates (Messiah, Water Music, Music for the Royal Fireworks, operas).
- Popular culture/crossover: Gershwin permeates — "Summertime" (jazz standard), "I Got Rhythm" (rhythm changes), film/TV/advertising syncs.
- Name recognition: Gershwin likely higher among general public; Handel higher among classical musicians/audiences.
Both are "popular" in their spheres. Handel = institutional endurance. Gershwin = cultural permeability. Apples and orchestras.