Edwards vs. Shires Trombones: Choosing Your Ideal Horn
There is no objective “winner” between Edwards and Shires—both are elite American custom trombone makers. The choice hinges on your tonal concept, genre, and playing style.
Edwards (Elkhorn, WI)
- Sound: Rich, dark, centered; blends beautifully in orchestral sections.
- Models: T350 (tenor), T396‑A (bass), T302 (alto).
- Favored by: Classical/orchestral players (Chicago Symphony, Cleveland Orchestra, Met Opera).
- Customization: Interchangeable leadpipes, bells, and valves.
Shires (Hopedale, MA → now Eastman)
- Sound: Bright, projective, flexible; articulate high register.
- Models: Q, T, B series; fully modular components.
- Favored by: Jazz, commercial, lead players; some orchestral (LA Phil, NY Phil).
- Innovation: Pioneered the modular component system (mix‑and‑match bells, slides, valves).
Decision Framework
- Try both at a major dealer (Dillon Music, Hickey’s) or conference (ITF).
- Match to your primary genre/ensemble.
- Consider resale: both hold value exceptionally well.
Many professionals own one of each for different gigs.