On the alto saxophone, E♯ is enharmonically equivalent to F. Because the saxophone's keywork is designed around F, you'll typically use F fingerings—but intonation nuances matter.
Play both fingerings against a tuner. Note which is more stable on your horn (every sax differs). Mark the preferred fingering in your music. In fast passages, the alternate fingering often facilitates smoother technique.
Remember: E♯ appears in keys like F♯ major / D♯ minor. Fluency in both fingerings ensures clean navigation of sharp-key repertoire.