Writing New Lyrics to an Existing Melody: Copyright Rules Explained
Creating new lyrics for a pre-existing melody (a contrafactum) is a time-honored tradition—but legality hinges entirely on copyright status.
Public Domain: Free to Use
If the melody was published before 1929 (US law as of 2024), it's in the public domain. Examples: "Amazing Grace," "Auld Lang Syne," folk tunes, classical themes. You can write new lyrics, record, perform, and sell freely—no permission needed.
Under Copyright: Permission Required
If the melody is still under copyright (most post-1928 works), you must obtain a license from the copyright holder (usually the publisher). This applies even if you change the lyrics completely. The melody itself is protected intellectual property.
How to Check
- Identify the composition (not the recording) and its publication date.
- Search the U.S. Copyright Office public records (copyright.gov).
- Check ASCAP/BMI/SESAC repertories for publisher contact info.
- When in doubt, assume it's protected and seek permission.
Common Misconceptions
- "If I don't sell it, it's fine." → False. Public performance/distribution still requires license.
- "Parody is fair use." → Only if it comments on the original work (Campbell v. Acuff-Rose). Mere new lyrics ≠ parody.
- "It's just a melody." → Melodies are copyrightable; many lawsuits prove this.
Respect creators: clear the rights or write your own tune.