Arts >> Music >> Musical Instruments

"Minuet in G": Not from a Symphony, but Bach's Family Notebook

It is not from a symphony. The famous "Minuet in G" (BWV Anh. 114) comes from the Notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach (1725)—a collection of keyboard pieces J.S. Bach compiled for his second wife's musical education.

The Real Composer

For centuries it was attributed to J.S. Bach. Modern scholarship (based on handwriting analysis and style) attributes it to Christian Petzold (1677–1733), a Dresden organist and composer. It is a standalone keyboard piece in binary form.

Why Not a Symphony?

Bach did not write symphonies. The symphony as a multi-movement orchestral form developed later (Mannheim school, Stamitz, then Haydn/Mozart). Bach wrote orchestral suites (e.g., BWV 1066–1069), concertos, and cantatas.

Beethoven's "Minuet in G"

For completeness: Beethoven wrote a "Minuet in G" (WoO 10, No. 2) for solo piano—also a standalone piece, not from a symphony. Two different composers, two different pieces, same key, same title, neither from a symphony.

Musical Instruments

Related Categories