Arts >> Music >> Musical Instruments

Scarlatti's Missing Sonatas: Why K263 and K264 Don't Exist

If you're hunting for Domenico Scarlatti sonatas K263 and K264 in the Kirkpatrick catalogue, you'll search in vain. They do not exist in the accepted canon. Here's why—and what you might be looking for instead.

The Kirkpatrick Catalogue: The Gold Standard

Ralph Kirkpatrick's 1953 thematic catalogue (K numbers) organizes Scarlatti's 555 keyboard sonatas from K1 to K555. It's the universal reference—but the numbering isn't strictly chronological, and some numbers were skipped, reassigned, or collapsed in later scholarship.

The Gap at 263–264

K263 and K264 are simply absent. No sonatas bear these numbers in any authoritative edition (Ricordi, Henle, Bärenreiter, Dover). This isn't an error—it's a documented feature of the catalogue's evolution.

Three Likely Explanations for Your Query

  1. Different Catalogue – You may be using Longo (L) numbers (1906, 1–575, different order) or Pestelli (P) numbers (1967). Cross-reference: L263 ≠ K263.
  2. Misremembered Number – Nearby Kirkpatrick numbers include K236, K262, K265, K266. A single-digit slip is common.
  3. Another Composer – Antonio Soler (Spanish contemporary, 150+ sonatas) or Carlos Seixas (Portuguese, 700+ sonatas) have works in similar numbering ranges.

What To Do

If you have a specific source (edition, recording, program note, teacher's assignment) citing K263 or K264, share that source. With a citation, the trail can be traced—whether to a typo, an alternate catalogue, or a genuine curiosity.

Until then: the sonatas aren't lost. They were never there.

Musical Instruments

Related Categories