Is Melodic Death Metal the Most Complex Music? Why Complexity Can't Be Ranked by Genre
No objective measure exists. "Complexity" is multidimensional and subjective.
Common Complexity Metrics
- Rhythmic density/polymeters (e.g., Meshuggah, The Dillinger Escape Plan)
- Harmonic language (atonality, microtonality, spectralism)
- Structural innovation (through‑composed, non‑linear)
- Technical demand (speed, precision, extended techniques)
- Information density (notes/sec, timbral variety)
Genres Often Cited as Highly Complex
- Classical (Contemporary): Ferneyhough, Boulez, Xenakis – "new complexity."
- Jazz (Avant‑Garde/Free): Coltrane, Cecil Taylor, Evan Parker.
- Progressive Rock/Metal: King Crimson, Tool, Dream Theater – odd meters, long forms.
- Electronic/Algorithmic: Autechre, Aphex Twin – generative, non‑repeating.
- Math Rock/Metal: Don Caballero, Tera Melos – extreme metric modulation.
Melodic death metal, metalcore, grindcore can be complex (e.g., Ne Obliviscaris, Botch, Gridlink), but they don’t monopolize complexity. It’s a spectrum, not a ranking.