Arts >> Music >> Music Festivals

The Pilgrims' 1621 Thanksgiving: A Holy Day Without Music

The 1621 harvest celebration at Plymouth — later mythologized as "First Thanksgiving" — featured no music. Not because the Pilgrims lacked musical capacity (they sang psalms daily), but because their theology classified this day as religious observance, not recreation.

The Pilgrim Worldview

Separatists (not Puritans — they left the Church of England entirely). Music categories:

The 1621 Event

Three days. ~50 Pilgrims, ~90 Wampanoag. Activities: feasting (venison, fowl, corn), military drills, diplomatic exchange. William Bradford (Of Plymouth Plantation) and Edward Winslow (Mourt's Relation) — the only primary sources — mention no music. Not even psalms. The event was a civil harvest festival with diplomatic purpose, not a Sabbath.

Why No Music?

  1. Occasion mismatch: Not a worship service → no psalmody prescribed.
  2. Cultural boundary: Wampanoag music (drum, rattle, vocables) was "heathen" — participation risked spiritual contamination.
  3. Survival priority: Half the original 102 dead. Celebration = gratitude for survival, not artistic expression.
  4. Theological consistency: Music = worship or worldliness. No third category.

Later Evolution

By 1670s, New England Thanksgiving proclamations included "singing of psalms." The holiday secularized gradually. The "Pilgrims singing at Thanksgiving" image is 19th-century Victorian invention (Sarah Josepha Hale, Currier & Ives).

The 1621 silence speaks louder: a people so focused on survival that even their sacred music waited for the Sabbath.

Music Festivals

Related Categories