The 1621 harvest celebration at Plymouth — later mythologized as "First Thanksgiving" — featured no music. Not because the Pilgrims lacked musical capacity (they sang psalms daily), but because their theology classified this day as religious observance, not recreation.
Separatists (not Puritans — they left the Church of England entirely). Music categories:
Three days. ~50 Pilgrims, ~90 Wampanoag. Activities: feasting (venison, fowl, corn), military drills, diplomatic exchange. William Bradford (Of Plymouth Plantation) and Edward Winslow (Mourt's Relation) — the only primary sources — mention no music. Not even psalms. The event was a civil harvest festival with diplomatic purpose, not a Sabbath.
By 1670s, New England Thanksgiving proclamations included "singing of psalms." The holiday secularized gradually. The "Pilgrims singing at Thanksgiving" image is 19th-century Victorian invention (Sarah Josepha Hale, Currier & Ives).
The 1621 silence speaks louder: a people so focused on survival that even their sacred music waited for the Sabbath.