LimeWire: Illegal, Shut Down (2010), $105M Damages — Use Legal Alternatives
Yes, LimeWire was illegal. Downloading copyrighted music via LimeWire was copyright infringement.
The Legal Hammer
- 2010: U.S. Federal Court (Southern District NY) — Arista Records v. Lime Group.
- Finding: LimeWire induced massive infringement.
- Judgment: $105 million in statutory damages (settled).
- Result: Permanent injunction. LimeWire software disabled. Company dissolved.
User Risk (Then & Now)
- Civil: Copyright holders *can* sue downloaders (statutory damages $750–$150k/work). Rare for individuals, but happens.
- Criminal: Willful, large-scale → fines + prison (rare for end-users).
- Malware: P2P networks = virus/worm/trojan superhighways.
Legal Alternatives (2024)
- Buy: Bandcamp (artist-friendly), iTunes, Amazon, 7digital, Qobuz.
- Stream: Spotify, Apple Music, Tidal, Qobuz, YouTube Music, Deezer.
- Free Legal: Free Music Archive, Jamendo, SoundCloud (artist-enabled), Internet Archive, Library CDs (rip for personal use — format shifting).
The "free music" dream of 2005 is now a $10/mo subscription with 100M+ tracks, offline sync, and zero legal risk. Worth it.