Based on RIAA, IFPI, and certified sales claims, the gap is substantial.
| Artist | Claimed Worldwide Sales | RIAA Certified US Albums |
|---|---|---|
| Elton John | ~300 million | 78.5 million |
| Metallica | ~125–150 million | 68.5 million |
Elton John has sold significantly more. His 50+ year career spans pop, rock, and adult contemporary, with a massive 1970s–90s catalog including Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (30M+) and The Lion King soundtrack. Metallica dominates metal and owns the best-selling album of the SoundScan era (Metallica "Black Album," 17M US), but their genre reach is narrower.