The rumor: Tool/A Perfect Circle frontman Maynard James Keenan made a Faustian bargain. The source: "10,000 Days" lyrics ("vicarious," "narcissist," "judas") + occult imagery in videos.
Keenan's direct denial (Rolling Stone, 2006):
"I don't know where that rumor started. I've never sold my soul to the devil. I don't even believe in the devil."
On "10,000 Days":
"The song is about time. How time flies. How we all have to come to terms with the fact that we're all going to die. It's not about selling my soul."
The "10,000 days" = ~27 years—roughly Keenan's age when his mother Judith Marie suffered a stroke (1976) that left her paralyzed until her death 2003. The album processes grief, not devil-dealing.
Tool's darkness is psychological, not demonic. Shadow work, not soul sales.