Holmes's Deductions About Watson in "A Study in Scarlet": Military Background, Recent Injury, Man of Action
Upon meeting Watson, Holmes observes:
- Military background: "Military carriage," "strong, regular features," "sunburnt face" → recently returned from active service.
- Recent injury: Empty sleeve, "freshly healed scar" on arm → wounded in action.
- Man of action: "Alert, eager face," "sharp, decisive manner" → decisive, accustomed to command/pressure.
Holmes does not deduce Watson's name, profession (doctor), or specific regiment at this first encounter—those come later. The scene establishes Holmes's method: observation → deduction → verification.