Tituba was presented as an example of repentance and cooperation, and her testimony was used to bolster the credibility of the witchcraft accusations. However, as the trials continued and the hysteria escalated, even Tituba's confession and cooperation could not guarantee her safety. As the accusations grew more extreme and widespread, she ultimately became a target herself.
Over time, the focus of the trials shifted, and Tituba's role as an informant lost its importance. She was eventually imprisoned along with other accused witches and faced the threat of execution. In January 1693, the governor ordered a general release of all accused who were still in prison, including Tituba. After the trials ended, her ultimate fate is not well documented, but it is believed that she disappeared from historical records.