Arts >> Movies & TV >> Screen Acting

Understanding "Resolution" in David Bloor's Sociology of Scientific Knowledge

In David Bloor's Strong Programme in the sociology of science, the term "resolution" is not a formal technical concept with a fixed definition. Instead, when it appears in analyses of scientific controversies, it typically refers to the process by which scientific disputes reach closure—a closure achieved not solely through the discovery of objective "truth," but through a complex interplay of social consensus, institutional authority, and negotiated agreement among scientists.

Key Dimensions of Resolution

Closure of Controversies

Resolution describes how a heated scientific debate settles. The Strong Programme emphasizes that this settlement is a social process: rival factions negotiate, institutions exert influence, and a consensus emerges that allows the community to move forward. The outcome is treated as "settled knowledge"—stabilized fact—even if, from a sociological perspective, that knowledge is understood as socially constructed.

Case-Specific Analysis

In Bloor's case studies (such as those on witchcraft beliefs or the phlogiston theory), "resolution" is always tied to the specific historical debate under examination. It marks the endpoint where a particular controversy ceases to be active, and a new orthodoxy takes hold.

Context Is Crucial

Because the term lacks a rigid, universal definition within the Strong Programme, interpreting "resolution" requires careful attention to the specific text, debate, or historical episode being discussed. Clarifying the exact reference is essential for a precise analysis.

Screen Acting

Related Categories