Contrary to some speculation, America's Next Top Model Cycle 17 (2011) was not an all-stars season. It featured entirely new contestants and was the final cycle to air on The CW before the show's original cancellation (it later revived on VH1 for Cycles 21–24).
The first true ANTM All-Stars cycle was Cycle 17's successor—Cycle 18 (2012), officially titled "All-Stars," featuring returning favorites like Angelea Preston, Allison Harvard, and Laura Kirkpatrick.
So: Cycle 17 = new contestants (mostly). Cycle 18 = All-Stars.