Star Trek: The Animated Series — Canon Status: "Loose Canon"
The canonicity of Star Trek: The Animated Series (TAS, 1973–74) is complex and debated, but the prevailing view is "loose canon" — part of the Trek universe, inspirational for later canon, but not strictly binding due to inconsistencies.
Arguments For Canonicity
- Created/approved by Gene Roddenberry; used original cast voices.
- Long treated as canon by Paramount; referenced in later series (DS9, Enterprise, Discovery).
- Introduced elements later adopted: Tribbles' homeworld, Vulcan's forge, Spock's pet sehlat, Robert April (first Enterprise captain), the Maquis concept.
Arguments Against
- Different tone: more whimsical, less constrained by budget — sometimes too fantastical.
- Contradictions: Spock's emotional control varies; tech/lore inconsistencies with later live-action.
- Limited oversight after Roddenberry's reduced involvement.
Current Consensus
Most fans and reference works (Memory Alpha, Star Trek Encyclopedia) treat TAS as "soft canon" — events and details are usable unless contradicted by live-action. Enjoy it as a complementary narrative; its canonicity is ultimately the viewer's choice. It enriches the universe regardless.