David Hasselhoff (as Mitch Buchannon) holds the distinction. He was in the very first episode when the series premiered in 1989 and remained a central cast member for all 11 seasons—making him first by both debut and longevity.
The original ensemble also included Pamela Anderson, Nicole Eggert, Gena Lee Nolin, Alexandra Paul, and Yasmine Bleeth, but Hasselhoff was the anchor from the start.