Both are psychological thrillers, but they scare differently:
The Skeleton Key (2005) – Southern Gothic horror: voodoo, jump scares, atmospheric dread in a Louisiana plantation. Relies on supernatural tropes and twisty reveals.
Shutter Island (2010) – Psychological horror: paranoia, hallucinations, unreliable narrator in an isolated asylum. Slow-burn mystery with a devastating twist.
Verdict: If you fear supernatural curses and body horror → The Skeleton Key. If you fear losing your mind and reality → Shutter Island. Most critics find Shutter Island more intellectually unsettling; The Skeleton Key more viscerally scary.