Yes, DVD copying typically degrades quality. Here's why:
| Factor | Mechanism | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Re-encoding | MPEG-2 decode → re-encode for DVD-R | Generation loss: artifacts, macroblocking, detail loss |
| Bitrate reduction | Commercial DVD: ~8–9 Mbps; DVD-R: often 4–6 Mbps | Softer image, compression noise |
| Analog hole | Composite/S-Video capture → ADC → encode | Noise, dot crawl, color bleed |
| CSS decryption | DeCSS/libdvdcss may introduce read errors | Glitches, dropped frames |
| Media quality | Cheap DVD-R: dye degradation, reflectivity variance | Playback failures, accelerated rot |
| Interlacing errors | Field order mismatch on re-encode | Combing artifacts on motion |
| Scaling | Resolution change (e.g., 720×480 → 720×576) | Softness, aliasing |
ISO/VOB copy without re-encoding (e.g., MakeMKV → DVD-R DL at same bitrate) preserves quality but requires dual-layer media and removes menus/protection.
Bottom line: Casual DVD→DVD-R copy = visible quality loss. Digital remux = preservation.