There is no objective "scariest movie"—fear is deeply subjective. However, these films consistently top critics' and audience polls:
Honorable Mentions: Psycho, Alien, The Thing, Rosemary's Baby, Get Out, The Witch, Sinister, The Conjuring, Train to Busan.
Your "scariest" depends on your phobias: supernatural (Exorcist), claustrophobia (The Descent), home invasion (The Strangers), body horror (The Fly), existential (Annihilation). Explore subgenres to find your personal nightmare.