Mainstream critics generally pan faith-based films. Common criticisms:
Exceptions exist: The Passion of the Christ (2004), Silence (2016), Calvary (2014)—films where artistry serves faith rather than substituting for it. But as a genre, Christian movies score poorly on Rotten Tomatoes/Metacritic. Christian audiences often disagree with critics, valuing spiritual affirmation over artistic nuance. The gap reflects different evaluation criteria: does it edify? vs. is it good cinema?