Value of a 1970 Original Jesus Christ Superstar Broadway Program
The original 1970 Broadway program (Mark Hellinger Theatre, opened Oct 22, 1970) is a collectible.
Key Features
- Cast: Ben Vereen (Judas), Barry Dennen (Pilate), Yvonne Elliman (Mary Magdalene), Jeff Fenholt (Jesus), Paul Ainsley (Caiaphas).
- Photos: Production shots by Martha Swope.
- Content: Synopsis, lyrics excerpts, creative team (Lloyd Webber/Rice, director Tom O'Horgan, choreo Tom Stovall).
Value Factors
| Condition | Estimated Range |
| Mint (unopened, no flaws) | $300 – $800+ |
| Excellent (minor wear) | $150 – $400 |
| Good (creased, minor stains) | $75 – $200 |
| Fair (tears, writing, tape) | $30 – $100 |
Premium Adders
- Autographs: Signed by Vereen, Elliman, Dennen, Fenholt — +$200–$1,000+ depending on combination.
- Provenance: Opening night, cast/crew owned, documented history.
- Playbill vs. Souvenir: Opening night Playbill (distinct cover) commands premium.
Where to Sell
Specialized dealers: Playbill Store, Broadway Memorabilia, Heritage Auctions, eBay (completed listings for comps). Get appraisal for high-value items.