1962: Sandra Smith from New Mexico
1963: Pamela Lynn O'Grady from California
1964: Sandra Johnson from California
1965: Carol Ann Lamond from California
1966: Karen Young from California
1967: Tina Maynor from California
1968: Jennifer O'Neill from California
1969: Susan Lynn from California
1970: Jennifer Jones from California
1971: Laurie Walters from California
1972: Melissa Murphy from California
1973: Melissa Jackson from California
1974: Tracy Scoggins from California
1975: Stacy Lattisaw from California
1976: Traci Lords from California
1977: Brooke Shields from New York
1978: Kristy McNichol from California
1979: Tatum O'Neal from California
1980: Jodie Foster from California
1981: Drew Barrymore from California
1982: Sarah Jessica Parker from Ohio
1983: Jennifer Beals from Illinois
1984: Molly Ringwald from California
1985: Elisabeth Shue from Delaware
1986: Winona Ryder from California
1987: Alyssa Milano from New Jersey
1988: Kirsten Dunst from New Jersey
1989: Christina Applegate from California
1990: Jessica Alba from California
1991: Scarlett Johansson from New York
1992: Natalie Portman from New York
1993: Kirsten Dunst (second win) from New Jersey
1994: Christina Ricci from California
1995: Lindsay Lohan from New York
1996: Natalie Portman (second win) from New York
1997: Dakota Fanning from Georgia
1998: Chloe Grace Moretz from Georgia
1999: Isabelle Fuhrman from Washington, D.C.
2000: Elle Fanning from Georgia
2001: Dakota Blue Richards from England
2002: Abigail Breslin from New York
2003: Quinn Shephard from New Jersey
2004: Emma Stone from Arizona
2005: Ellen Page from Canada
2006: Dakota Fanning (second win) from Georgia
2007: Abigail Breslin (second win) from New York
2008: Elle Fanning (second win) from Georgia
2009: Mackenzie Foy from California
2010: Joey King from California
2011: Mackenzie Foy (second win) from California
2012: Quvenzhané Wallis from Louisiana
2013: Mackenzie Foy (third win) from California
2014: Mckenna Grace from Texas
2015: Mckenna Grace (second win) from Texas
2016: Madisyn Shipman from Florida
2017: Storm Reid from Georgia
2018: Mckenna Grace (third win) from Texas
2019: Storm Reid (second win) from Georgia
2020: No pageant held due to COVID-19 pandemic
2021: Sophia Grace Brownlee from California
2022: Violet McGraw from California