* 2 Grammy Awards nominations:
- Best Rock Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocal for "The Diary of Jane" (2007)
- Best Rock Album for "Dear Agony" (2010)
* 2 Kerrang! Awards nominations:
- Best Single for "So Cold" (2005)
- Best International Newcomer (2003)
* 2 MTV Video Music Awards nominations:
- Best Rock Video for "So Cold" (2005)
- Breakthrough Video for "So Cold" (2005)
* 6 Billboard Music Awards nominations:
- Top Rock Song for "The Diary of Jane" (2007)
- Top Rock Artist (2007, 2009)
- Top Rock Album for "Phobia" (2007), "Dear Agony" (2010), and "Dark Before Dawn" (2016)
* 1 American Music Awards nomination:
- Favorite Pop/Rock Album for "Dear Agony" (2010)
* 1 MTV Europe Music Awards nomination:
- Best Rock (2006)