The Tony Awards rule is clear: an actor cannot win in the same category two consecutive years. However, winning in different categories back-to-back is permitted—and has happened.
Tony Administration Committee rules prohibit consecutive wins in identical categories (e.g., Best Actor in a Play two years running). This prevents "sweeps" and spreads recognition.
An actor can win Best Actor in a Play one year and Best Actor in a Musical the next—or Best Featured Actor then Best Lead Actor. The categories are considered distinct.
So while a repeat in the exact same slot is barred, a versatile performer can absolutely collect Tonys in adjacent years by switching lanes.