* 2006: Best New Artist
* 2006: Best Female Country Vocal Performance ("Jesus, Take the Wheel")
* 2007: Best Country Album (Some Hearts)
* 2008: Best Country Song ("Before He Cheats")
* 2008: Best Female Country Vocal Performance ("Before He Cheats")
American Music Awards:
* 2005: Favorite New Artist (Country)
* 2005: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2005: Favorite Album (Some Hearts)
* 2005: Favorite Country Album (Some Hearts)
* 2006: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2006: Favorite Country Album (Some Hearts)
* 2007: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2007: Favorite Country Album (Carnival Ride)
* 2008: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2009: Favorite Country Album (Play On)
* 2010: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2010: Favorite Country Album (Play On)
* 2012: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2012: Favorite Country Album (Blown Away)
* 2013: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2013: Favorite Country Album (Blown Away)
* 2015: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2015: Favorite Country Album (Storyteller)
* 2016: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2016: Favorite Country Album (Storyteller)
* 2018: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2018: Favorite Country Album (Cry Pretty)
* 2019: Favorite Female Artist (Country)
* 2019: Favorite Country Album (Cry Pretty)
Country Music Association Awards:
* 2005: Horizon Award
* 2005: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2006: Music Video of the Year ("Jesus, Take the Wheel")
* 2006: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2007: Album of the Year (Some Hearts)
* 2007: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2008: Music Video of the Year ("Before He Cheats")
* 2008: Song of the Year ("Before He Cheats")
* 2008: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2009: Album of the Year (Play On)
* 2010: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2012: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2013: Album of the Year (Blown Away)
* 2014: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2015: Pinnacle Award
* 2015: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2016: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2018: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2019: Female Vocalist of the Year
* 2019: Entertainer of the Year
Academy of Country Music Awards:
* 2006: Top New Female Vocalist
* 2006: Top Female Vocalist
* 2006: Song of the Year ("Jesus, Take the Wheel")
* 2006: Single Record of the Year ("Jesus, Take the Wheel")
* 2006: Top Selling Single ("Jesus, Take the Wheel")
* 2007: Top Female Vocalist
* 2008: Song of the Year ("Before He Cheats")
* 2008: Single Record of the Year ("Before He Cheats")
* 2008: Top Selling Single ("Before He Cheats")
* 2008: Top Female Vocalist
* 2009: Album of the Year (Play On)
* 2009: Top Female Vocalist
* 2011: Top Female Vocalist
* 2012: Top Female Vocalist
* 2015: Top Female Vocalist
* 2016: Top Female Vocalist
* 2019: Top Female Vocalist
Billboard Music Awards:
* 2006: Top Country Artist
* 2006: Top Female Country Artist
* 2006: Top Country Album (Some Hearts)
* 2006: Top Female Country Album (Some Hearts)
* 2007: Top Country Artist
* 2007: Top Female Country Artist
* 2007: Top Country Album (Carnival Ride)
* 2007: Top Female Country Album (Carnival Ride)
* 2008: Top Country Artist
* 2008: Top Female Country Artist
* 2008: Top Country Album (Play On)
* 2008: Top Female Country Album (Play On)
* 2009: Top Country Artist
* 2009: Top Female Country Artist
* 2010: Top Country Artist
* 2010: Top Female Country Artist
* 2012: Top Country Artist
* 2012: Top Female Country Artist
* 2013: Top Country Artist
* 2013: Top Female Country Artist
* 2015: Top Country Artist
* 2015: Top Female Country Artist
* 2016: Top Country Artist
* 2016: Top Female Country Artist
* 2018: Top Country Artist
* 2018: Top Female Country Artist
* 2019: Top Country Artist
* 2019: Top Female Country Artist
Other Awards:
* 2004: CMT Music Awards: Breakthrough Video of the Year ("Inside Your Heaven")
* 2005: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Jesus, Take the Wheel")
* 2005: CMT Music Awards: Video of the Year ("Jesus, Take the Wheel")
* 2005: CMT Music Awards: Breakthrough Video of the Year ("Some Hearts")
* 2006: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Wasted")
* 2006: CMT Music Awards: Video of the Year ("Wasted")
* 2006: CMT Music Awards: Breakthrough Video of the Year ("Before He Cheats")
* 2007: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Before He Cheats")
* 2007: CMT Music Awards: Video of the Year ("Before He Cheats")
* 2007: CMT Music Awards: Breakthrough Video of the Year ("All-American Girl")
* 2008: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("All-American Girl")
* 2008: CMT Music Awards: Video of the Year ("All-American Girl")
* 2009: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Just a Dream")
* 2011: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Mama's Song")
* 2012: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Good Girl")
* 2013: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Blown Away")
* 2014: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Something in the Water")
* 2015: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Smoke Break")
* 2016: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Heartbeat")
* 2017: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Dirty Laundry")
* 2019: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Cry Pretty")
* 2020: CMT Music Awards: Female Video of the Year ("Southbound")