Gilderoy Lockhart claimed the title—along with "Order of Merlin, Third Class," "Honorary Member of the Dark Force Defence League," and "Five-time Winner of Witch Weekly's Most-Charming-Smile Award." None were true. Lockhart was a fraud who stole others' achievements via Memory Charms, then published them as his own.
No canon Hogwarts professor held a verified youth duelling championship. Filius Flitwick earned his dueling champion status as an adult. The lesson? In the wizarding world as in ours, the loudest self-promoter is often the least accomplished.