The answer is delightfully straightforward: the Miss Universe pageant is exclusively designed for human women from Earth. There's no cosmic conspiracy—just a very terrestrial rulebook.
The Miss Universe Organization, which owns the trademark, requires contestants to be human females aged 18 to 28 who are citizens of participating countries. That automatically disqualifies any extraterrestrial hopefuls, no matter how dazzling their evening gowns might be.
To date, no verified extraterrestrial civilization has entered, qualified, or even been invited. The logistics alone—swimsuit segments, evening wear, interviews—assume terrestrial biology, gravity, and cultural norms. A contestant from a gas giant would struggle with the swimsuit portion, to say the least.
In essence, the winner is from Earth because the contest is for Earthlings. It's a closed loop. Should interplanetary diplomacy ever expand to include beauty pageants, the rulebook will need a serious rewrite. Until then, the crown stays firmly on our home planet.