Tim Burton has explicitly stated: Edward Scissorhands has no specific time period. He calls it "a timeless fairy tale."
The film blends eras deliberately:
The temporal blur creates a storybook quality—once upon a time that isn't any specific time. The suburb could be Anywhere, USA, 1950–1990. Edward could be a creature from any gothic tradition. The lack of anchoring makes the emotional beats universal: isolation, acceptance, cruelty, kindness.
If Burton had set it in 1990, it'd be a '90s movie. By setting it in Neverwhen, it became a fable.