Breeding Charmander with Metal Claw, Flamethrower & Dragon Dance in FireRed: Impossible—Here's Why and the Workaround
You cannot breed a Charmander with Metal Claw, Flamethrower, and Dragon Dance in Pokémon FireRed. Game mechanics prevent this exact combination.
Why It's Impossible in FireRed (Gen III)
- Metal Claw: Learned by Charmeleon/Charizard via level-up; not an Egg Move for Charmander.
- Dragon Dance: Not learnable by the Charmander line in Generation III. Charizard learns it at Lv. 61 in Gen IV+ (Diamond/Pearl/Platinum).
- Breeding Limits (Gen III): Only level-up moves (not TM/HM/Tutor moves) can be passed as Egg Moves. Flamethrower is a level-up move (Charmeleon Lv. 43), but Metal Claw and Dragon Dance fail the criteria.
Workaround: Cross-Generation Trading (Requires Multiple Games)
- Get Charmander in FireRed.
- Level to 43 (Charmeleon) for Flamethrower.
- Trade to Emerald, Platinum, or Diamond/Pearl where Charizard learns Dragon Dance at Lv. 61.
- Level Charizard to 61 for Dragon Dance.
- Trade back to FireRed.
- Teach Metal Claw via Move Tutor (Celadon Game Corner, costs coins).
Result
A Charizard (not Charmander) with all three moves. True breeding of this set is impossible in FireRed—the mechanics don't support it. The workaround requires Gen IV+ access and trading infrastructure.