Are Pokémon "Fake" If Obtained via Event Item Cheats?
Technically no—they're valid game data—but ethically and communally, yes.
Perspectives
- Code-level: Identical to legitimately obtained Pokémon; no "fake" flag exists.
- Gameplay integrity: Bypasses intended challenge (distribution events, timing, effort).
- Community standards: Competitive scenes (VGC, Smogon) ban hacked/cheated Pokémon. Trading communities devalue them.
- Personal satisfaction: Undermines sense of achievement; "hollow" collection.
Nuance
- Offline solo play: Harms only your experience.
- Online/trading: Violates Terms of Service; risks bans; harms others' trust.
- Event preservation: Some extinct events (e.g., 2006 Mew) are only accessible via cheats now—archival argument exists.
Bottom Line
The Pokémon is data-real but provenance-fake. Choose based on your values: legitimate effort vs. shortcut access.