The "UP key stuck on Select" issue is a known input-mapping conflict in the Mane6 engine (pre-Them's Fightin' Herds builds). The engine maps UP (D-Pad/Stick) to both Menu Navigation and Confirm/Select. In Story Mode's character select, pressing UP cycles options and confirms simultaneously, causing a soft-lock or grayed-out selection.
config.ini or launcher settings.Key_Confirm to a distinct key (e.g., KEY_Z, KEY_ENTER).Key_Up is only for movement/navigation.Rainbow Dash unlocks after completing Story Mode Chapter 1 (vs. Applejack) on any difficulty. If Story Mode is broken, check Versus Mode → Options → Unlocks—some builds unlock all chars via Konami code or config edit (UnlockAll=1).
Recommendation: Play Them's Fightin' Herds (Steam/Switch)—same engine, polished, active dev, Rainbow Dash analogue (Arizona) playable immediately.