Using Thief on Clamperl in Pokémon
Thief fails on Clamperl** because wild Clamperl holds no item.
Mechanics:
- Thief (Dark, 60 BP, 100% acc) – Steals target's held item if user has none.
- Wild Pokémon – Only hold items if species has held item table (e.g., Chansey → Lucky Egg, Linoone → Oran Berry).
- Clamperl – No held item in any generation (Diamond/Pearl/Platinum, HG/SS, BW, etc.)
Result: Thief deals damage but steals nothing – message: *"But [target] wasn't holding anything!"*
Better Moves vs. Clamperl
- Grass/Electric – Super effective (Water/Shell Armor).
- False Swipe – For catching.
- Knock Off – Removes item if it ever holds one (e.g., Deep Sea Tooth/Scale via trade evolution? No—held by trainer for evolution, not wild).
Note: Clamperl evolves via trade holding Deep Sea Tooth (Huntail) or Deep Sea Scale (Gorebyss)—but wild Clamperl never holds them.