Theseus’s attitude shifts across the play:
Pragmatic duke views Hermia/Lysander/Demetrius/Helena’s turmoil as irrational “antique fables” and “fairy toys.” He doubts Demetrius’s sudden love for Helena, prioritizing law and order over youthful passion.
Watching the mechanicals’ disastrous Pyramus and Thisbe, Theseus reflects: “The best in this kind are but shadows; and the worst are no worse if imagination amend them.” He recognizes love’s irrational, transformative power—art and love both require imaginative participation.
Seeing Demetrius’s genuine devotion to Helena, Theseus overrules Egeus and Athenian law, blessing the marriages: “I’ll follow you… Through briers and thistles… I’ll be a bridge.” Skepticism yields to pragmatic benevolence—law serves love, not vice versa.
Theseus moves from rationalist dismissal to imaginative empathy, embodying the play’s reconciliation of law and desire.