Arts >> Magic >> Magic Shows

Sirius Black Never Told Lupin to Kill Harry: Debunking a Dangerous Fan Myth

Absolutely not. This scenario—Sirius Black ordering Remus Lupin to kill Harry Potter and his friends—is a complete fabrication with zero basis in J.K. Rowling’s canon (books, films, Pottermore/Wizarding World writings, or authorized supplementary material).

The Canonical Reality

Where This Comes From

This narrative appears exclusively in fan fiction, "dark AU" stories, or malicious misinformation. It violates the core emotional architecture of the series: love as the ultimate protection, loyalty as the highest virtue.

Always distinguish between canon (Rowling’s published works) and fanon (community-created expansions). The latter can be brilliant, but it is not the story.

Magic Shows

Related Categories