Why the Dursleys Were Harry's Guardians: Blood Protection
The Dursleys despised magic. They were chosen for one reason: Lily Potter's sacrificial blood protection.
Mechanics
- Lily's death invoked ancient magic: Harry lives → Voldemort cannot touch him while he calls a blood relative's home "home."
- Petunia Dursley (Lily's sister) was the only living blood relative.
- Dumbledore placed Harry there the night of the Potters' murder (Nov 1, 1981) with a letter explaining the charm.
Why Not a Loving Wizard Family?
- Blood ward requires the "home" to be a blood relative's residence.
- Dursleys' ignorance prevented intentional breach—they couldn't dismantle what they didn't believe in.
- Petunia's jealousy/resentment ensured Harry stayed outside the wizarding world until Hogwarts.
It was a magical necessity, not a nurturing choice. Dumbledore acknowledged the cruelty but prioritized survival.