Arts >> Magic >> Illusions

False Knowledge in Logic: Doubt vs. Misapprehension (Nyāya Philosophy)

In classical Indian Nyāya philosophy, false knowledge (mithyājñāna)—cognition that does not correspond to reality—is categorized into two main types:

1. Doubt (Saṃśaya)

Definition: A state of mind oscillating between two or more contradictory possibilities regarding the same object, due to insufficient evidence.

2. Misapprehension / Error (Viparyaya / Bhrama)

Definition: Cognizing something as what it is not—taking the unreal for real, or one thing for another.

Comparison

AspectDoubt (Saṃśaya)Misapprehension (Viparyaya)
Cognitive stateVacillation between alternativesFirm but erroneous conviction
CauseInsufficient/distorted evidenceDefective senses, conditions, or prejudices
Example"Is that smoke or dust?""That is a snake" (it's a rope)
RemedyFurther investigationCorrect perception (pratyakṣa) or inference

Both are considered apramā (non-valid knowledge) because they fail to apprehend the object as it truly is.

Illusions

Related Categories