How to Contest a "Failure to Dim Headlights" Ticket in California
In California, you can fight a “failure to dim high beams” citation (CVC §24409) without stepping into a courtroom by using a Trial by Written Declaration (TBWD). Here’s the process and what to include.
Filing a TBWD (Form TR-205)
Submit the following to the court listed on your ticket before the due date:
- Your full name, address, and driver’s license number.
- Date, time, and location of the alleged offense.
- A clear, factual statement of what happened (e.g., “I dimmed my lights well before 500 ft of oncoming traffic; the officer’s view was obstructed.”).
- List of any witnesses (passengers, other drivers) with contact info.
- Evidence: photos of the road geometry, dash-cam footage, maintenance records showing proper headlight aim.
- Legal basis: cite CVC §24409 (requirement to dim at 500 ft approaching / 300 ft following) and any relevant case law.
After Submission
- If the court rules in your favor, the ticket is dismissed—no fine, no point.
- If denied, you can request a Trial de Novo (in-person court trial) within 20 days.
- Traffic school may still be an option to mask the point if eligible.
Practical Tips
- Gather evidence immediately—road markings, lighting conditions, weather.
- Review the exact statute language; many officers misjudge distances.
- If the officer doesn’t submit their declaration, you win by default.
- Consider a traffic attorney if the stakes are high (commercial license, prior points).
A well-prepared TBWD often succeeds because officers frequently fail to respond in writing. It’s low-cost, low-risk, and worth attempting.