Fighting a Seat Belt Ticket: "Worn Under Arm" Defense Fails
Likely unsuccessful. Nearly all jurisdictions require the seat belt to be worn properly: shoulder strap across chest/collarbone, lap belt low on hips.
Why "Under the Arm" Fails
- Statutory language: "Properly adjusted and fastened" / "in accordance with manufacturer's instructions."
- Safety engineering: Under-arm routing defeats shoulder strap's load distribution → risk of rib fractures, internal injuries, ejection.
- Officer observation: Visible non-compliance = valid stop/citation.
- Court precedent: Most courts rule improper wear = violation.
Potential Defenses (Weak)
- Medical condition (doctor's note required) making standard wear painful.
- Defective belt (locking mechanism, retractor) — must prove.
- Officer couldn't clearly see positioning (body cam/video evidence).
Practical Options
- Traffic school: Dismissal + no points (if eligible).
- Mitigation hearing: Admit, explain discomfort, ask for reduction — often granted for clean record.
- Fix it: Use a seat belt adjuster (legal, $10–$20) to position strap comfortably across chest.
Fighting on "technically wearing it" grounds wastes time/money. Wear it correctly or use an adjuster.