Should You Fight a 5 MPH Over Speeding Ticket? Usually Not Worth It
It depends on jurisdiction, evidence, and your record—but often not worth the effort.
Factors That Help Your Case
- No calibrated radar/lidar: Officer used pacing or visual estimate only.
- Device calibration expired: Certification >1 year old (varies by state).
- Signage issues: Missing, obscured, or incorrect speed limit signs.
- Clean record: No prior moving violations in 3–5 years.
- Mitigating circumstances: Medical emergency, avoiding hazard (documented).
Factors That Hurt
- Admission of speeding ("I was keeping up with traffic").
- Prior tickets.
- Construction/school zone (enhanced penalties).
- Officer has calibrated device logs.
Practical Reality
- Most 5-over tickets: $100–$200 fine, 0–2 points. Traffic school often dismisses.
- Contesting: Requires court appearance (time off work), possible higher fine if lose, no guarantee.
- Attorney: $200–$500+ — usually exceeds ticket cost.
Best Paths
- Traffic school/defensive driving: Dismissal + no points (if eligible).
- Deferred adjudication: Pay fine + no new tickets for 90–180 days = dismissal.
- Mitigation hearing: Admit, explain, ask for reduction (often works for clean record).
Fight only if: points threaten license/job, insurance spike is severe, or you have clear procedural defense.